Evil-Dog's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Blob Wars: The First Game]

Not a very good game

but you're gay and can't accept it, so you put your frustration into homophobic games.

[Wonderland 3D RPG (fixed)]

Your other Wonderland games were better

Alright dude, it's not quite good here
first the graphics are pretty bad, ugly swish graphics, why didn'T you draw the character instead of doing them with 3D ? it would look much better !!
The game play and the layout of your game is quite amateur too, the colors and the text fonts and size are really weird and cheap...use a better color scheme and smaller fonts it will look way more professional.
then there's the gameplay problems...you can't go back from the abandonned building ? there's no real RPG elements...no stats...no character building...no choices...nothing about a RPG...a game with some quests isn't a RPG you know.
You can't go out of the quest building...
then you have like 0.00001 second to kill a zombie with 1 hit ??? there's something wrong man...then the game ends, you ask us to vote 5 and say everything is done by you and don't mention my music which isn't done by you hehe
anyway, you see there's a lot of weak points in your game, I see you're pretty young too and it's quite good for your age, 13 or so....so keep it up

omega3D responds:

!!! Sorry! I forgot to add you in the credits, huh? Crap!!! I really didn't mean to. Sorry. Anyway, I completely agree with everything you said. I take your advice more than anyone elses. You know that, right? Well, anyway, I am working on a game (.html and .js, so I won't be able to put it on newrounds) that is a REAL rpg, with stats, character upgrades, items, skills, choices, etc... so e-mail me if you get the chance, please. I really need to speak to you in person about... stuff...
Anyhow, my new e-mail is [e-mail]
thats mega, zero, m, three, g, a. That's the correct spelling.

[Project: Prime Evil 1]

It's alright

The intro was really cool, then the actual game was "ok"
the blood was badly made, and the whole thing didn't quite grasp my interest, and you got the review crew pick award with 16 reviews ? haha that's lame, considering your score...I wanted the award hehe
Anyway keep it up, try working on your graphics and a more interesting gameplay.
It's probably just not my type of game, ignore what I say

[(old)Dance-O-Matic V1.0]

Hehehe

Nice try there.

TheComet responds:

Thx.
I'm working on this still. I was actually intending this to be a BETA but for some reason I called it V1.0...
Bttw, how'd you make a long bar for the tracks? For V2, all I'm really going to end up doing is resizing the boxes to half their size or something to make more fit...O.o

[Rekindled 0.3]

Blah.

Unfinished game, no sounds, stolen concept
Come on be original and finish your stuff before putting it here.

mooseproduce responds:

Well, it's a sequel with permission from the original. Sorry about the unfinishedness, but I'm using Newgrounds as a temporary host for it... :P Hopefully I can get a real host going soon.

[Area51]

Awesome !

Hey dude don't listen to all those losers who can't make a damn thing but still says that your game sucks.
it's a great game and I like the humor, it also scared the shit out of me when the first creature poped out haha
A lot of effort went in there it's obvious
Keep it up !

[Tip-A-Cow]

haaa....originality :D

Congrats man, this is great.
but I hate you for making me press my buttons so intensivly...it's painful everytime haha
The graphics were awesome, simple and efficient.
(the different levels were extremely well styled.)
The sounds were adequate and good choice on the musics.
The whole concept is very original and that's why I liked it, there isn't much replay value tho, that's probably the biggest down of your game.

Keep it up man. Great effort and great result.

AngryAxel responds:

Wow, Evil-Dog, king of the Audio Portal... Im honored ^_^

Yes, I did have plans on adding a score system, so that players could compete or something, but it never got through... Well, thanx for the review!

[The Dungeon]

Wow : original !

Hey there, good work

Some people talk about cheating, what's the point in cheating, just don't play if you don'T wanna play with the rules haha

I think that was great...
here's a couple things you should add for the next version
- moving objects, not just on/off objects
- better graphics
- change the mouse cursor (use Mouse.hide() and use dragging with a movieclip that will be the cursor...)
- add better, less repeating music, more fitting, like my music for instance ! haha :P j/k but yeah I have some ambient medieval music that could fit with your dungeon if you wanna use them.
- Add different sounds for each death...

That'S about it

You had a cool idea ! Keep it up !

[Wonderland 3D World 2]

Worse than the first one

Hi again
I was dissapointed cause you didn't take enough time to polish your game, test it and all...there are several bugs, like when you're in front of the portal you can't go back the bottom button does the same thing as the teleporter button, so it's kinda anoying and you lost some point on the interactivity,

anoter place there's no place to click, you have to guess and there's no clue so it's a little weird...

personnaly, I liked the riddle...but you'll see that NG people are lazy.

keep it up (Spend more time to enhance the game experience next time, with longer puzzles, bigger world, sounds, etc)

Peace
Evil-Dog

potbellybob responds:

Well, this was actually the first game initially, but I had to cut the first game in half because it was like 4.959 mgs. Be a good dog. I'm going to make a better game than this one, and the first one. So keep your eyes out for my new games. (also look on geocities/flashgamearchive/index.html for the rest of my games.) Evil-Dog, please understand. You are my hero, and I want to use only your music for my games. Maybe not the same loops on all of them, so please make some more of that music.

[Wonderland 3D]

Nice work man !

I'm glad you liked and used my music, it's the first good submission that use my music and you made a good choice, it fits very well :)

It took me a little while to figure out what the number-pad does :) I was like "how the hell am I suppose to know what the correct code is..." then I went back...woah...I'm in a different place...I finally finish the game
It's kinda like myst ! nice work

Constructive comment : Add sounds for the actions, like a sound for the lever or when you click the button and go to another place, and sounds for some of the places, like an outside-mood ssounds you know. and a little more animation with the 3D would be nice too, like moving clouds or something like that.

keep it up
the 3D was cool

Evil-Dog

potbellybob responds:

The Evil-Dog himself! I can't believe I actually met him! I would like to talk to you sometime -- my e-mail is [e-mail] and yes, I have YIM. The idea for the game DID come from Myst, by the way, and I'm glad yet another person noticed. Thanx for the review!